Three strikes, and we’re (edged) out.

Three strikes, and we’re (edged) out.

Emaryllis hasn’t always reported each attempt to get a desired cultivar into the gallery in great depth, but we have at least noted mislabeling frustrations in the effort to document ‘Cutting Edge’, an Israeli variety with few available photos online. Several years back it was purchased as a dry bulb by mail-order, and later in 2016, 2019, and again in 2020 the only way it could be found…in an expensive bulb kit. These are not the traditional box kits with a pot, media, and loose bulb to plant. The “box” is actually a glazed ceramic cachepot, no drained grower’s pot to sleeve within included in this case.

Our boxless subject opened; a bagged bulb waits inside.

The stats, save for price, are much the same in all three cases over the years. The ceramic pot is from Portugal (Smith and Hawken branded), the coir disc is from Sri Lanka, and the bulb (claimed at 26-28cm circumference) is from Israel, though that is not noted. The kit is assembled and sold by the Netherland Bulb Company of Pennsylvania. This year, the price of the kit (found at a tony local nursery) was a whopping US $28.99. Similar kits with other varieties from the same supplier could be had for less. With both weary trepidation, and that good old Emaryllis spirit of hopefulness, the purchase was made November 10, 2020. Don’t think for a moment that paying sky high prices will insure either labeling correctness or performance…but we can hope, right?

Curiously, there are other kits from the same supplier at the shop. The tag featuring a photo of ‘Charmeur’ immediately grabs my attention, as that cultivar hasn’t been around for years.

Curioser still…the label indicates ‘Tinkerbell’, a stablemate to ‘Cutting Edge’. Surely they have plenty of stock photos of their own hybrid, right?! Perhaps the smaller 24-26cm bulb claim size is the reason for the more reasobable price.

There are other ceramic pot kits using bulbs from Saad-Assaf/Amaryllis IL on offer, including standard “open stock” varieties, but also their own magnificent ‘Ruby Star’ and for the first time in a kit, the pastel and peachy ‘Tinkerbell’.

Here it is, the complete kit. The bulb is devoid of live roots, but meets the minimum claim size by measuring 26cm around. We have modest hopes for performance.

The main reason for featuring the attempt to get ‘Cutting Edge’ this year is simple. In the time between purchasing the kit and writing this up, both Saad-Assaf and Amaryllis IL have updated their websites. Not only is ‘Cutting Edge’ gone, but similar “coming soon” ‘Minuet’, the spectacular favorite ‘Sophisticate’ and a host of others have disappeared. New varieties are being developed and introduced to give the companies a truly well-rounded amaryllis portfolio…but this was probably the last hope of getting ‘Cutting Edge’.

While the ceramic cachepot is very nice, it doesn’t offer drainage which is not horticulturally sound. It joins a collection of two other such containers. The bulb is planted in a 5.5″/14cm pot using our own potting medium. There is a tiny bit of foliage peeking from the top, and one just-starting flower scape on the side. We should be all set!

Though the bulb included in the kit did meet the minimum size requirement, it did not have any live roots. With luck (and warmth) it will strike some new roots to propel vigorous growth and proper bloom. The bulb was potted up, watered, and placed under lights November 13, less than 48 hours after purchase. The pandemic has allowed one good thing, plenty of time on hand!

Nice! What a beautiful and subtle amaryllis we have here. While it has a light picotee edge, it isn’t really cutting it!

The first scape opened its blooms around December 18, a little more than a month after potting up. The 16″/40.5cm scape produced four flowers, each with a familiar plain cream and green face with minimal red picotee edging. No boisterous and frilled picotee edge nor red brushed face of ‘Cutting Edge’ here, but rather the more subtle beauty of the grower’s most similar offering, ‘Emerald Dawn’. With four flowers on the first scape, this is not the best the cultivar can do, but certainly acceptable so long as you don’t mind the mislabeling part. For the record, Emaryllis does mind the mislabeling part.

Decent performance, and just the right amount of foliage to balance the display. The second scape yields six blooms and tops out at 18″/46cm which is not so tall as to provoke toppling…no stakes required!

While we are fans of ‘Emerald Dawn’, the wind has gone out of our sails as we realize that our last chance to see ‘Cutting Edge’ has faded just as these flowers have opened.

The second and final scape bears the more usual six flowers. Getting two scapes with four flowers each is our minimum expectation, so at least we got ten flowers total, a reasonable show if not a great dollar value.

As the holiday lights offer splashes of color in and out of the home, and the amaryllis bench is vibrant with opening flowers, the cool and enchanting beauty of ‘Emerald Dawn’ steps in with its own welcome balance. While always appreciated in its own right, the bittersweet reality that we may never get the chance to sample its more lively sibling ‘Cutting Edge’ confers just a touch of melancholy to its quiet beauty.

4 Comments on “Three strikes, and we’re (edged) out.

  1. How frustrating! Can’t say I’m surprised though – far too often my expensive named amaryllis bulbs have ended up looking nothing like the name on their label! I now have a rule that I don’t spend over £5 (that’s under $7 USD) – at least that way, I haven’t wasted too much money if they are not as advertised!

    In spite of restrictions, I was able to get 2 box kits from my local food store and mail ordered another 3 bulbs – waiting to see how they will flower. Also waiting for last year’s ‘Christmas Star’ to flower – it didn’t bloom last year, so I have no idea if it will be Christmas Star or not – if not, this will be my THIRD non-Christmas Star.

    • Agreed, Philippa! Price doesn’t predict better outcomes for amaryllises. There are some pricey suppliers that generally have good sized bulbs and rarely have major labeling errors, but there are less expensive firms that do just as well. It is those really inexpensive bulbs (and kits) that come off as the most amazing value.

      • Sigh! Three strikes and we’re out here too – ‘Christmas Star’ is not fully opened yet, but I can see enough to know it is NOT as labelled – streaked/veined pinky red with a green/white midrib and green/white tips. Just glad I only paid £2 for it, out of the end-of-season bargain trolley. If I’d paid the full price of £15 (over $20USD) I’d have been really annoyed!

        When it’s fully open, can I email you a pic to see if you can ID it for me?

        • Well, you are a savvy shopper! Its a lot easier to take a mislabel when you havn’t parted with too much money. Please do send your photo along for ID whenever you’d like.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.